Everything changed one Tuesday in October. Not all at once, but like an invisible crack that slowly widens until it causes an entire structure to collapse. Gregory McCarthy simply wasn’t looking at the right load-bearing walls.
In the kitchen of their Portland home, he watched his nine-year-old son, Dylan, meticulously and almost obsessively arrange his collection of vintage baseball cards. It was a rigor Gregory recognized in himself. His wife, Melissa, moved about the room with a familiar grace, preparing a salad for Sunday dinner at her parents’ house.
These Sunday meals at the Merrills’ had been part of the ritual for eight years. Gregory endured them with the same stoic patience as his most difficult customers.
« Dad, do you think Grandma Sherry will want to see my cards? » asked Dylan, his eyes shining.
« Maybe just leave them here, champ, » Gregory replied, ruffling his hair. « You know how she is with her furniture. »
Melissa gave him a brief, sharp look. They’d had this conversation before, in a thousand unspoken forms. His mother, Sherry Merrill, was demanding, controlling, intrusive. Gregory had grown up in a broken home; the apparent stability of Melissa’s family had initially seemed reassuring. It had taken him years to understand that stability could also be a cage.
The Merrill house in Lake Oswego was a large, impeccably maintained home. Melissa’s father, Raymond, a retired insurance executive, lived there quietly, almost withdrawn. Sherry opened the door before they even knocked.
« There’s my favorite grandson! » she exclaimed, hugging Dylan a little too long.
Dinner followed its usual pattern: Sherry monopolized the conversation, which focused almost exclusively on Dylan. Gregory watched, uncomfortably, this constant, almost possessive attention. After the meal, while Melissa helped her mother in the kitchen, Gregory found himself with Raymond in the study, leafing through an old photo album.
« Melissa, at Dylan’s age, » Raymond said, pointing to a picture. Then, in a low voice: « She was happy back then. » He fell silent abruptly.
The moment passed. It was at the cafe that Sherry brought out the gift.
She presented Dylan with a carved wooden box, clearly old and expensive.
« It’s something very special, darling. But open it when you’re alone, okay? It’s a secret. »
An immediate chill settled in Gregory’s stomach.
« Why a gift to open alone? » he asked.
« It’s between a grandmother and her grandson, » Sherry replied, a fixed smile on her face. « Don’t be so paranoid. »
Melissa placed a soothing hand on Gregory’s arm. The message was clear: let it go.
That night, Dylan fell asleep with the box on his bedside table. Gregory didn’t sleep. At two in the morning, he went down to the office with the box. The latch gave way without resistance.
Inside, dozens of photographs. Dylan, in the bathroom of the Merrill house, asleep during stays, sometimes altered, diverted. Below, a handwritten journal.
Gregory closed the box, trembling. Rage, horror, and guilt overwhelmed him.
Melissa appeared in the garage, alerted by the noise. Gregory handed her the box.
« Don’t open it if you don’t want to know, » he said in a subdued voice.
She opened it. The box fell from her hands.
« My mother… is a predator, » she whispered.
They immediately called the police.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
